"The Smoke Rise Village Inn, nestled in the heart of the beautiful Smoke Rise community of Kinnelon, has long been thought of as a private dining facility able to be used only by its residents." That is the Inn describing itself on its own à la carte dining page. The page goes on to say that the Inn "is not only open to the public but that the food and service are second to none."
That changes the usual answer to where to eat in Kinnelon. The borough's other restaurants sit along a short stretch of Kinnelon Road, Boonton Avenue and Route 23. Add the Inn to that list, and Kinnelon covers breakfast through a fireplace dinner without a trip to a neighboring town.
The Dining Room in an 1892 Dairy Barn
The Inn is at 9 Perimeter Road. According to the Inn's history page, the stone building dates to 1892 and housed a dairy business for years. It became a restaurant in 1947, "created to serve as the social hub of its small community." The building still has its cobblestone courtyard and country gardens. Inside, the interior has been renovated, and there's a lounge with a fireplace where you can have cocktails and dinner. The Inn also has an enclosed gazebo room for private dinner parties and a main ballroom for larger events.
Executive Chef Joseph Bottani runs the kitchen. The Inn says it holds the Five-Star Diamond Award from the American Academy of Hospitality Sciences and calls itself one of only a few places in New Jersey with that distinction.
The Inn's posted hours run dinner from 5 to 9 p.m. on Tuesday and Wednesday and from 5 to 10 p.m. Thursday through Saturday. Private parties can be booked seven days a week. Happy hour runs Tuesday through Friday from 3 to 6 p.m., which suits a weeknight drink before heading home. The dinner, dessert, specialty drinks and happy hour menus are posted together on the Inn's site.
The Inn also does holiday cooking. Last November it advertised a Thanksgiving buffet with roasted turkey and stuffing, carved prime rib and bourbon butternut squash. It also offered take-out packages for groups of up to 4, 8 or 12, with orders due the Friday before the holiday. This year's Thanksgiving is Thursday, November 26, so call the Inn directly to confirm its 2026 plans. For December gatherings, the gazebo room and ballroom are the spaces to ask about.
Breakfast and Lunch on Boonton Avenue
The rest of Kinnelon's dining week starts on Boonton Avenue. Comfort Kitchen Cafe, at 104 Boonton Ave., is open Tuesday through Friday from 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. and on weekends from 8 a.m. to 4 p.m. Kinnelon residents David and Brianna Soule own it. The cafe serves breakfast, lunch, espresso and fresh-baked pastries. It also sells take-away dinners, so you can stop for coffee in the morning and pick up the evening meal on the same visit.
San Giorgio's Italian Bistro is a short walk away at 86 Boonton Ave. Its menu covers pasta, veal, steaks, chicken and fish, and reservations can be made through the bistro's visit page. Between the two addresses, one stretch of Boonton Avenue handles a weekend breakfast and an anniversary dinner.
A Wood-Fired Oven on Kinnelon Road
Cypress Tavern, at 174 Kinnelon Road, keeps the longest hours in town: Monday through Saturday from 11:30 a.m. to midnight, and Sunday from noon to 8 p.m. On its about page, the tavern says its owners' dream of running a food business was inspired by Cyprus. The kitchen centers on a custom wood-fired oven and artisan pizzas. It also has a bar with custom cocktails, patio dining, online ordering, and catering for private events.
Cypress Tavern is the obvious choice when you want a late dinner after a weekday game or a Saturday meal that runs past 10. It's also the most flexible place in Kinnelon for a group: sit at the bar, order to the table, or take pizza home.
Pizza at the Kinnelon Mall, Thai on Route 23
Farther down Kinnelon Road, the Kinnelon Mall at 25 Kinnelon Road has the borough's everyday pizza stop. Esposito's Pizzeria lists that address on its ordering site. Its hours run from 10:30 a.m. to 8:45 p.m., and the menu has pizza, pasta, salads and other Italian dishes.
Out on Route 23, House of Thai is in Unit 05 of the Meadtown Shopping Center at 1483 Route 23. The restaurant's menu runs from pad thai at $15.95 to five curries, red, green, panang, massaman and yellow, at $16.95 each, with lunch versions at $12.95. Kinnelon Bagels is also listed among the center's tenants, in Unit 09.
What the Borough Has Proposed Behind Meadtown
Behind the Meadtown Shopping Center sits the former Meadtown Theater, which has been vacant since 2013. In December 2024 the borough presented its investigation of whether the parcel should be designated an area in need of redevelopment. The draft housing plan describes the parcel as designated in 2024. It says the borough was working with the owner and a developer on a proposed mixed-use building with retail or restaurant space and 20 apartments, three of them affordable. That is a proposal in a planning document, and borough meeting agendas are the place to follow its progress.
A Kinnelon Week of Eating Out
Put together, the list covers a full week. Saturday starts with pastries and espresso at Comfort Kitchen Cafe and can end at Cypress Tavern's bar any time before midnight. A weeknight drink fits the Village Inn's 3-to-6 happy hour, and if dinner goes past 9, plan it for Thursday, Friday or Saturday. A Tuesday with no time to cook can be pizza from Esposito's or curry from House of Thai. San Giorgio's handles the dinners that need a reservation. For a December party, the Inn has the fireplace lounge, the gazebo room and a stone dairy barn's worth of history. Hours change around the holidays, so a quick call before you go is the safest plan.
If you're new to the borough, our Kinnelon neighborhood page and our earlier look at Kinnelon's lake communities cover more of the area around these addresses.
At The Weiss Group, we work in Kinnelon every week, and this list is our answer to the where-to-eat question. If you're thinking about a move within Kinnelon or nearby and want a calm, local conversation about it, schedule a free consultation. The first coffee can be at Comfort Kitchen.